This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Mother’s Day Sale Coming Soon! UP TO 40%OFF



Made-to-Order takes about 10 days, 2-5days for shipping

Diamond Resale Value: How Much is Your Diamond Worth?

Diamond Resale Value: How Much is Your Diamond Worth?


In a rapidly changing diamond market, where lab-grown stones are gaining ground, and natural diamonds face declining demand, many are questioning the true resale value of their diamonds. This guide aims to unravel the complexities of diamond valuation in today's market, offering insights into key influencing factors and actionable steps to maximize your return on investment. Whether you own a natural or lab-grown diamond, this guide equips you with the essential knowledge to navigate this fluctuating market confidently.

The Four Cs and Their Impact on Resale Value


The carat weight of a diamond is often the first thing people consider when assessing its value. While it's true that larger diamonds are generally more valuable, it's crucial to remember that a diamond's weight should be evaluated in conjunction with its other characteristics. For example, a larger diamond with poor clarity or color may not necessarily fetch a higher resale price than a smaller diamond with excellent clarity and color.


The cut of a diamond is an intricate art that impacts how the stone interacts with light, thereby affecting its brilliance and sparkle. A diamond with an "Excellent" cut grade can command a higher resale price than one with just a "Good" or "Fair" cut. The cut also influences how large the diamond appears; a well-cut diamond may appear larger than its actual carat weight, potentially increasing its resale value.


While colored diamonds have their own niche market, colorless diamonds are generally considered more valuable. The GIA's D-to-Z grading scale serves as an industry standard for evaluating a diamond's color. A high-grade colorless diamond (D, E, F) can significantly outperform a lower-grade (M, N, O) one in terms of resale value. Click to learn about: What is GIA?

What is GIA?


Clarity is a measure of a diamond's internal and external imperfections, known as inclusions and blemishes. Diamonds with fewer imperfections receive a higher clarity grade and, by extension, a higher resale value. However, some inclusions are microscopic and don't affect the diamond's appearance to the naked eye, making it essential to balance clarity with the other Cs when considering resale value. To access more content: WHAT IS DIAMOND CLARITY?

The Rise of Lab-Grown Diamonds

Lab-grown diamonds have indeed disrupted the traditional diamond market. They offer not just cost-effectiveness but also an ethical edge, appealing to a new generation of socially conscious consumers. However, it's essential to note that lab-grown diamonds depreciate in value more quickly than natural diamonds. So, if resale value is a consideration, natural diamonds maintain a distinct advantage.

Read more: Lab-grown diamond emerges from the shadows of natural diamonds.

The Rise of Lab-Grown Diamonds

Brand and Certification

The brand name can add a premium to the resale value of a diamond. For instance, a diamond from Tiffany & Co. could fetch up to 20% more on the resale market than a similar non-branded diamond. Certification from reputable labs like GIA authenticates not only the diamond's Four Cs but also its origin, whether natural or lab-grown, further influencing its resale value.

For more info: Can Lab-Grown Diamonds Be GIA Certified?

The diamond resale market is sensitive to broader economic conditions and consumer preferences. The increasing demand for lab-grown diamonds has put downward pressure on the resale values of certain natural diamonds, especially those with lower grades in the Four Cs. Additionally, economic downturns can lead to reduced luxury spending, affecting the liquidity of the diamond resale market. Therefore, timing your sale to coincide with favorable market conditions can maximize your diamond's resale value.

Market Trends and Economic Factors

How to Maximize Your Diamond's Resale Value

Get a Professional Appraisal

One of the first steps in maximizing your diamond's resale value is obtaining a professional appraisal. An expert gemologist can provide a detailed analysis of your diamond's quality based on the Four Cs-Carat, Cut, Color, and Clarity. This appraisal not only gives you a realistic expectation of what you can fetch on the resale market but also serves as a credible document for potential buyers.

Keep All Documentation

Documentation can significantly impact the resale value of your diamond. Original certificates from reputable labs like the GIA, as well as purchase receipts and previous appraisals, offer a transparent history of your diamond. These documents validate the quality and authenticity of your diamond, making it more appealing to buyers and potentially increasing its resale value.

Consider Re-cutting or Re-setting

Trends in diamond cuts and settings evolve over time. If your diamond is of an older cut that's less popular today, or if it's set in a style that has fallen out of fashion, you might consider re-cutting or re-setting it. However, this is a delicate process that should only be undertaken by professionals, as improper cutting can reduce the diamond's weight and value. A modern cut or setting can make your diamond more appealing to today's consumers, thereby increasing its resale value.

Sell to a Reputable Buyer

The channel through which you sell your diamond can also impact its resale value. Selling to a reputable buyer-whether it's a well-known jeweler, a specialized diamond resale website, or a high-end auction house-ensures that you'll get a fair and accurate price. These entities have the expertise to properly evaluate your diamond based on current market conditions and consumer demand.

Steps to Calculate Diamond Resale Value

Calculating the resale value of a diamond involves multiple variables, each contributing to the final figure. Here's a step-by-step guide to help you estimate how much your diamond might be worth on the resale market.

1.Identify the Carat Weight

The carat weight of your diamond is the starting point for any valuation. Knowing the exact weight of carats is crucial. For instance, let's assume you have a 1-carat diamond.

2.Determine the Price Per Carat

The next step is to find out the current market value per carat for a diamond with similar characteristics-Cut, Color, and Clarity. Researching recent sales or consulting industry reports can provide this information. In our example, let's say the current market price per carat for a similar diamond is $5,000.

3.Consider the Brand Multiplier

Brand recognition can add a premium to your diamond's value. If your diamond is from a renowned brand like Tiffany & Co., it could fetch a higher price. If it's not, the brand multiplier would be 1. In our example, the diamond is not from a famous brand, so the brand multiplier remains 1.

4.Factor in Market Conditions

The diamond market is not static; it's influenced by various factors, including the rise of lab-grown diamonds. To account for current market conditions, you can apply a market factor. In this example, due to the increasing popularity of lab-grown diamonds, we'll use a market factor of 0.9.

Find out more: Can Lab-Grown Diamonds Be Detected?

5.Type of Diamond

Lastly, consider the type of diamond you have. Natural diamonds generally command a higher resale value compared to lab-grown diamonds. In our example, the diamond is natural, so the Type Factor is 1.

The Calculation of Diamond Resale Value:

Resale Value= (Carat Weight)×(Price Per Carat)×(Brand Multiplier)×(Market Factor)×(Type Factor)

Based on these variables and the current market conditions, the estimated resale value of your 1-carat natural diamond($5,000)would be approximately $4,500. However, for the most accurate and personalized valuation, consulting a professional appraiser is highly recommended.


The resale value of a diamond is influenced by a myriad of factors, from its inherent qualities like the Four Cs to external elements like market trends and economic conditions. While lab-grown diamonds are making waves in the industry, natural diamonds still offer a higher resale value, especially if they are from reputable brands and have proper certification. By understanding these factors and taking proactive steps, you can maximize the resale value of your diamond, making it a truly valuable investment for the future.

Read More

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

Use coupon code WELCOME10 for 10% off your first order.


Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $200 away from free shipping.

No more products available for purchase